So I was reading
this fascinating post by
angiej, who was one of the first writers I read when I was first experimenting with fandom back in 2001, in which she discusses, among other things, the myopia that often plagues fans and how different things look once you've left that behind. Which is ... interesting, and I'm not sure I agree but it's certainly given me something to think about.
And she also says:
The rabbit hole gets darker once you go beyond this point... and I've been there, so deep that I will never be able to run for elected office *anywhere*, ever. After all, taken out of context, you could make a case that I've written what looks very much like kid characters screwing each other's brains out. Het or slash, canon-era or post-Hogwarts, to the eyes of an increasingly polarized and conservative 21st century world, it really doesn't matter... you are extra special once you start doing that.Which... huh, I'd never thought of it like that, either. And again, not sure I agree, but the bit about running for elected office also makes me pause. Because the reason Ebony falls into that particular category is not just because she's written smut (though it is quite good smut, and she could run for some sort of smut-related office I'd think), but because she's both written smut and gone online
using her real name.
And I've always been conflicted about that, myself. I've never once typed my real name into anything fannish-related (except that I did, out of a bizarre sense of guilt, have it on my name badge at Nimbus, but I covered it up). Not that I plan to ever run for elected office (but you never know, I guess) but, well, better safe than sorry, I've always thought. I might decide I want to adopt from China, or go on a reality show or date a Bush twin or something. Granted, when I first resigned myself to a lifetime of fannish anonymity I never dreamed that I'd one day be posting fanfiction in which teenage girls drink each others' menstrual blood, but seeing as how I've since gone to that "extra special" place, as Ebony puts it, I'm quite glad I decided to invent "Anna Maria Moss."
But then... it would also be kind of nice to someday decide to create something really cool in the non-fannish world, and to then be able to say, "Look, I've done all this too." I mean, yeah, I'm certainly not a BNF or whatever, but I've established myself online, I've written some stuff that I like, and I'll never be able to share any of it with anyone outside the little fannish bubble. Last year, I was dating a girl who was really eager to read some of my "writing," and I realized I had pretty much nothing I could send her -- even if I copied and pasted something into a Word document and changed the names, she'd still have been able to Google passages and wind up at my website and/or LJ in two clicks. Which was not a risk I was willing to take, or probably will be anytime soon. Just, for example. Obviously I know I can share stuff about my fannish existence with RL people on a case-by-case basis, but for me that's still quite a leap.
And I guess that's what happens when you draw that line. I'm still glad I came down on the side I did, of course, but still... yeah.
I always run out of steam when I try to write things like this. Just pretend this paragraph contains an interesting, thoughtful, witty conclusion, okay?